Hello, dear listener. I’m Megan, host of this series. And before we get into the show,
I wanted to take a minute to tell you about our sponsor, FIRE, the Foundation for Individual
Rights and Expression. We live in a moment when free speech, the bedrock of our democracy
and of all free societies, is often viewed as suspect, where many argue that the right
to free speech is too dangerous, and that even listening to ideological opponents is
morally wrong. Many people just don’t see a problem with using the law, corporate power,
and even extraordinary social pressure to censor viewpoints they disagree with. But
many of us feel the costs of all this in our everyday lives. We feel it when we self-censor,
afraid to say what we really think, sometimes even in private conversations with friends
or loved ones. We feel it when we opt out of a growing number of public discussions,
afraid of the potential cost to our jobs and even our relationships. FIRE shares a mission
with this show, to remind us why a culture of free speech and open dialogue matters.
And regardless of how loud the calls for censorship are, FIRE’s defense of that culture is unshakable
and invaluable. And if you want to remember why we choose freedom, even for people we
strenuously disagree with, you can learn more about FIRE’s incredible work at thefire.org.
And now, on to the show.
The cave you fear to enter holds the treasure you seek. Joseph Campbell.
Chapter One. Plotted in Darkness.
Hello there. Sorry to bother you. I’m making a podcast and I’m going to be asking a lot
of fans a lot of questions all weekend and you’re one of the people not staring at your
phone. So I thought maybe start with this though.
How are you?
I’m good. How are you?
I’m doing good. For starters, why do you like Harry Potter?
I don’t know. I think I had not such a great childhood and I think a kid with not such
a great childhood actually escaped to something else in a book.
It’s a story about acceptance and love.
Harry Potter has been kind of like a beacon of hope in a lot of times in my life.
She teaches you the importance of friendships, the importance of forgiveness.
He felt like an outsider and he felt like he didn’t belong and that really resonated
I think it’s the way people pull together. They’re different. They don’t all exactly
agree with one another but they can say, okay, this is the common good and this is what we’re
going to work for.
What about the author? What about J.K. Rowling?
That’s a tricky question.
So there’s a lot of controversy with that one.
I’m trying to stay out of it.
I have a comment that I’ll say off the thing.
J.K. Rowling is one of the most successful authors in the history of publishing, and
for the past 25 years, she’s also been one of the most beloved.
Her books have taught tens of millions of children worldwide about virtues like loyalty
and courage, about the inclusion of outsiders and the celebration of difference.
But in the summer of 2020, Rowling published a string of tweets about one of the most polarizing
subjects in society right now, sex and gender.
She waded into a conflict about transgender rights and the way she believed some activists
were eroding hard-won rights for women.
There was an explosive reaction to Rowling’s tweets, which led many, including lifelong
fans of her work, to condemn her and to call for her books to be banned, boycotted, and
in some cases, burned.
So let me talk about the infamous book burning video for a second.
I am not just offended by what J.K. Rowling says.
I am fearful because of what she is promoting on her platform.
J.K. Rowling is literally putting trans lives at further risk.
She just is.
It’s disgusting and it’s problematic.
I mean, let’s face it, Hermione would punch this woman in the face right now.
The Harry Potter franchise is literally making this world unsafe for kids today.
Rowling was denounced by people she’d worked with for years, by staff at her publishers,
and by human rights organizations that had once lauded her.
Actors who had grown up on the Harry Potter film sets, people she had known since they
were children, distanced themselves from her.
Die-hard fans got their Harry Potter tattoos removed.
Some called for anyone supporting Rowling, even in small ways, to be fired from their jobs.
The condemnation moved to rallies, where Rowling became a symbol.
You are murdering trans children!
Just get off our town!
Just get off our town!
My name is Megan, and I spent the first 26 years of my life in a strict, fundamentalist
The beliefs of my church were the complete embodiment of my identity and my worldview.
My family taught me that we were on a mission from God himself, warning the world that they
were going to hell if they didn’t repent and live as we lived.
And I was a true believer, certain that I was 100% right, until I wasn’t.
Ten years ago, even though I knew it would cost me almost every relationship I had, including
with my parents, who I love so much, I left.
I’ve spent the decades since investigating belief and how it compels us to act and identify
and how it colors and shapes the world we inhabit.
And reading Rowling’s tweets, and then her transformation in the eyes of many who had
loved her, it surprised me.
Because growing up, it was my community that thought J.K.
Rowling was evil.
And it was other Christian fundamentalists who had amassed in force to condemn Rowling
and to call her work dangerous.
The Harry Potter books are mainstreaming witchcraft to our children.
They had denounced her.
They tried to ban Harry Potter from schools and libraries.
And in some cases, they burned her books.
God hates this.
I mean, he really hates it.
And he is light.
It is evil.
It’s a stepping stone, kind of like marijuana leading to crack.
The little kids, they don’t know the difference.
The adults do.
And that’s a shame on those parents to have their little kids read it.
When their kids commit suicide, I told them so.
I’ve been warned.
Despite its unparalleled popularity, Harry Potter is actually among the most banned books
of the 21st century.
And Rowling, even though she’s inspired profound adoration throughout her career with fans
all over the planet, she’s also been the subject of intense, widespread, and vocal
backlashes from people whose politics could not be more at odds.
And for the past year, I’ve been trying to figure out why.
What is it about this woman and her work that has captured the ire of very different groups
of people across time?
How did Rowling understand her critics?
And what did she think would happen when she sent those tweets?
And so I decided to write her a letter.
I explained who I was and what I was trying to understand, and then I sent it off to her
And to my surprise, I heard back.
I never set out to upset anyone.
However, I was not uncomfortable with getting off my pedestal.
And what has interested me over the last 10 years, and certainly in the last few years,
the last two, three years, particularly on social media, you’ve ruined your legacy.
Oh, you could have been beloved forever, but you chose to say this.
And I think you could not have misunderstood me more profoundly.
I do not walk around my house thinking about my legacy.
You know, what a pompous way to live your life, walking around thinking, what will my
I’ll be dead.
I care about now.
I care about the living.
After I left Rowling’s home, I spoke to reporters and historians, transgender adults, teens
and advocates, doctors and lawyers, and many of Rowling’s critics, including some who
supported book bans.
And one of the things that stood out to me was how people on all sides of this conflict
felt so under attack, so threatened, that they invoked the language of witch hunts,
even as they vehemently disagreed on who was the witch and who was the mob lighting the
I’m Megan Phelps-Roper, and these are The Witch Trials of J.K. Rowling.
Well, if you guys have water, you sound good, I’m going to put on these headphones.
Yeah, we closed that door, but it might need to be locked, actually.
Last summer, J.K. Rowling invited me to her 16th century stone house, where she lives
with her husband, her younger children, and two dogs.
Later I would Google the place and learn that it’s technically a castle, which from the
outside makes sense, but inside it felt smaller, cozy even.
The rooms were not high-vaulted and lofty, but snug and homey.
Think more hobbits in the shire, less princess in a tower.
Rowling was also smaller in real life than I would have guessed.
She showed my producer and me into her drawing room, filled with books that she’d color-coordinated
into a rainbow over the pandemic lockdown.
And it was here that we would sit together, over the course of the next few days, and
You have big, deep breaths.
Let’s do it.
Okay, so I want to start with a big question.
Why do you think we humans, especially young kids, why do we like stories about witches
and wizards and giants and dark magic?
What is it about us?
And what is it about magic and magical worlds that we find so compelling?
I’m very interested in this because I think it speaks to something very profound in human
Magic gives a person agency they wouldn’t otherwise have.
And I think that’s particularly appealing to a child because children inevitably are
Even children in happy families are relatively powerless.
And the idea that you have secret power, extraordinary power, supernatural power, I think is hugely
seductive to all of us, to adults as well, but particularly to children.
I want to go back to the early days, and I know you’ve talked about this period in
your life so much over the years, this time just before Harry Potter was published.
But I also know that our stories aren’t static.
They shift over time with the benefit of hindsight and new experiences and just where you are
in life when you’re telling the story again.
I know exactly what you mean.
I’ve been asked a million times about the moment when I had the idea on the train.
And I’ve said it so many times, but you do look back and suddenly you stumble into this
little pool of self-knowledge or memory that can be so illuminating.
So I had the idea for Potter on a train when I was 25.
Why did that idea come?
I’ve never really known.
It just fell into my head and I immediately thought, I’ve got to write that.
God, I love that idea.
The funny thing is I was never a great reader of fantasy.
The thing that interests me most is human nature above anything else.
Mr and Mrs Dursley of number four Privet Drive were proud to say that they were perfectly
Thank you very much.
They were the last people you’d expect to be involved in anything strange or mysterious
because they just didn’t hold with such nonsense.
But there was something about this particular story.
Perhaps it had something to do with living in a dark cupboard, but Harry had always been
small and skinny for his age.
Harry had a thin face, knobbly knees, black hair and bright green eyes.
He wore round glasses held together with a lot of scotch tape.
This boy who was unhappy and without any power suddenly realising what he had and who he
The only thing Harry liked about his own appearance was a very thin scar on his forehead that
was shaped like a lightning bolt.
He had had it as long as he could remember and the first question he could remember asking
his aunt Petunia was how he had gotten it.
Can you take me back to your life in the 1990s?
I’ve heard you describe that time as essentially your greatest fear come to life.
The early 90s for me were not good.
I was in a real period of flux at the time.
My mother was very ill.
I had moved from London to Manchester and then my mother died actually on the night
of December the 30th, 1990, but I didn’t realise she died until the early hours of
New Year’s Eve.
She was 45.
She’d been ill for a very long time, but none of us realised death was imminent.
That kind of took a wrecking ball to my life really.
To me this decade now was infused with loss and I think, you know, perhaps that would
have coloured my feelings about the story I was writing.
Perhaps that would have made me want to put it away forever.
But in fact, that sense of loss and this real despair that I felt started to go into
Harry was so close to the mirror now that his nose was nearly touching that of his reflection.
Mum, he whispered, Dad?
At that point, the story changed.
Suddenly everything darkened and deepened.
They just looked at him, smiling.
And slowly Harry looked into the faces of the other people in the mirror and saw other
pairs of green eyes like his, other noses like his, even a little old man who looked
as though he had Harry’s knobbly knees.
The story that Rowling had begun to write on the train that day was about an orphan boy.
I slightly glibly used the trope for six months before my mother died.
In reality, of course, it is a tragedy to be an orphan.
This fictional orphan, Harry Potter, was abused and neglected and never told about who he
really is, who his parents really were, or how they had died to save him.
And now I really understood what loss was.
Harry was looking at his family for the first time in his life.
The Potters smiled and waved at Harry and he stared hungrily back at them, his hands
pressed flat against the glass as though he was hoping to fall right through it and reach
He had a powerful kind of ache inside him, half joy, half terrible sadness.
This little manuscript, only I knew this story.
No one else had seen it.
I hadn’t spoken about it really to anyone else.
You know, this was the thing that I just clutched onto as I went off on my journeys.
In 1991, at the age of 25, Rowling broke up with her boyfriend, quit her job, and she
left the UK.
I decided I need to get away.
She got a job teaching English as a foreign language.
I went abroad.
I knew that I liked teaching and so I thought, I’m just going to go away.
I’m going to take a year out, I’ll teach.
I don’t really know why, but I chose to go to Portugal.
And initially it did the job.
I’m away, I’m in a different environment, this is helping me.
But I think that emotionally I was still incredibly vulnerable.
Well, in fact, I know I was emotionally vulnerable.
So while there was a lot of fun and there was relief in not being surrounded by the
familiar, I was pretty lost and pretending not to be lost.
Still grieving, unsure of what her future held, Rowling says she tried to put on a good
face and move forward.
And pretty soon, she met someone.
So you go to Portugal and you meet a guy.
I met a guy.
I think I’d been there six months, maybe, in a bar with my friends.
Good looking guy, told me he was a journalist.
We began dating.
It was okay.
It was okay.
I’d lost my moorings and I was drifting along in something that wasn’t perfect, but it was
good to be wanted.
It was good to have affection, but I was kind of adrift.
The months went by and eventually they decided to move into an apartment together.
A year came and it went.
And then I became pregnant accidentally.
And while pregnant, he proposed to me.
And then I lost the baby.
I miscarried, which was hugely traumatic.
It was traumatic physically and it was traumatic emotionally.
And that was another massive loss.
And I think at that point I really was in a very…
I was certainly not in a balanced state of mind.
And when I lost the baby, I do remember having a moment, in my grief for the baby, I do remember
having a moment where I thought, so we’re not going to get married.
That’s clear, right?
And I’m almost speaking to myself, that’s clear, Joe, we’re not going to marry this
But he was putting huge pressure on me to get married.
So I went through with it and then became pregnant almost immediately we were married,
which is a joyful thing because I cannot imagine a world without my Jessica in it.
So in with all the bad, there was an amazing, wonderful thing came out of it, and that was
But as I understand it, even before your daughter was born, your husband had become increasingly
Yeah, the situation was a bad situation, but until you actually go through it, you don’t
know what you would choose to do.
Rowling says she tried to end things.
I left him twice before I left for good, and then I went back twice.
But it just got worse from there.
The marriage at this point has turned very violent and very controlling.
At this point, he’s searching my handbag every time I come home.
I haven’t got a key to my own front door because he’s got to control the front door.
And I think he’s not a stupid person.
I think he knew or suspected that I was going to try and bolt again.
It was a horrible state of tension to live in because you have to act.
And I don’t think I’m a very good actor.
I don’t have a very good poker face.
And that was a huge strain to act as though I wasn’t going.
That’s a terrible way to live.
And yet the manuscript kept growing.
I’d continued to write.
In fact, he knew what that manuscript meant to me because at a point he took the manuscript
and hid it.
And that was his hostage.
When I realized that I was definitely going to go, this was it, I was definitely going,
I would take a few pages of the manuscript into work every day, just a few pages so he
wouldn’t realize anything was missing, and I would photocopy it.
And gradually in a cupboard in the staff room, bit by bit, a photocopied manuscript grew
and grew and grew because I suspected that if I wasn’t able to get out with everything,
he would burn it or take it or hold it hostage.
That manuscript still meant so much to me.
That was the thing that actually I prioritized saving.
The only thing I prioritized beyond that, obviously, was my daughter, but at that point
she’s still inside me, so she’s as safe as she can be in that situation.
In July of 1993, Rowling gave birth to a baby girl and named her Jessica, after one of her
favorite writers, Jessica Mitford.
She says it was this experience of motherhood that would ultimately push her to the point
where she had to make a change.
I do remember thinking very clearly, and that was probably at the moment I knew I had to
leave, about a month before I did leave, she’s not going to grow up and watch this happening
to her mother.
She’s not going to grow up and think that this is normal or okay.
So she started mapping out a way to get to her sister, who lived in Scotland.
I’d been planning a kind of orderly withdrawal.
I’d been trying to set things up so I get my daughter out, everything’s smooth, everything
But then there came a night, I don’t even know what triggered it, and this was probably
about a week before I’d planned to make my exit.
There came a night where he became very angry with me, and I crapped, and I said, I want
to go, I want to leave.
And he became very violent, and he said, if you’re leaving, you can leave, but you’re
not getting Jessica, I’m keeping her, I will hide her.
So I put up a fight, and I paid the price.
There was a very loud and violent scene, which terminated with me lying in the street.
And then I thought, right, I’m going to the police, and I went to the police, and I was
assessed, and I was agreed that I clearly had just been beaten up, I was pretty bruised,
and I filed a complaint.
And the next day, went back to the house with the police and got Jessica back.
Sitting where you are today is one of the most powerful, influential women in the world.
It almost seems like you’re describing a different person.
You know, you are a person without a key to your own flat, and you’re being physically
abused and beaten up, and smuggling out, plotting an escape.
But the thing is, I am still that person, you see.
To me, the through line is very clear.
Rowling and her daughter moved from Portugal to Edinburgh, Scotland.
With just a couple of suitcases, and next to nothing in her bank account, she was starting
When you moved back to the UK, what did your life look like?
Well, I’m not going to say it was as low as you can go, because it wasn’t.
I had very kind people who helped me.
I could go stay with my sister, which was obviously not the case for some people who
find themselves in my situation.
And I think I spent two, three weeks with my sister, and then I moved into my own place,
which was really a glorified bedsit.
Wait, a glorified what?
Do you not have that phrase?
What is that phrase?
I mean, it’s like a room and a half, you know?
So my first flat was like, there was a bathroom, but the kitchen, pretty much everything else
Oh, I see.
Like a studio apartment is equal.
Yeah, something like that.
So much more glamorous than bedsit.
And I called Jessica Decker, so Decker and I were sharing a bedroom.
Rowling said she was even more adrift than when she left the UK years before.
She was divorced, broke, a single mother, and she had just enrolled in a teacher training
program in hopes of eventually getting a job at a local school.
But I was living on benefits, which you would call welfare, obviously.
And I was, at this point, my mental health was not good.
I’d never lived in Scotland, although I have Scottish ancestry.
I was really here because my sister was here.
She felt isolated.
She was questioning her worth.
She didn’t have her mother there to help her become a mother.
She says that she was losing herself.
I was dissociating.
I was losing time.
I was, definitely had suicidal thoughts.
I was in a very dark, shaky place.
And yet it was this darkness, getting this low, that she now is almost grateful for.
It stripped away the inessential.
It showed me, even though I was a mess, candidly, I was a mess.
I had this daughter that I loved beyond anything in my life.
It was love like I’d never experienced before.
And that was so powerful.
And I do remember continuing to work on that story.
I spent 17 years working on Potter.
And there are things I understand in that story that no one else can possibly understand,
and which I stayed true to, even as my own life improved and my own state of mind became
I was still very committed to those parts that I’d plotted in darkness, as it were,
because there was a truth to them.
And there was a power to them.
But, you must know who your mum and dad were, he said.
I mean, they were famous.
What? said Harry.
My mum and dad were famous?
You don’t know?
Hagrid ran his fingers through his hair, fixing Harry with a bewildered stare.
You don’t know who you are?
I could have no idea what was going to come.
This podcast is supported by Athletic Greens.
I am a person who can be pretty obsessive about my health.
My routine typically includes things like 10,000 steps a day and smoothies and strength
And yes, I am even one of those people who forces myself to take cold showers, even in
But a lot of that flew out the window when I had a baby six months ago.
And I especially struggled to make sure that I was getting good nutrition.
That’s why I was so excited to add AG1 from Athletic Greens to my routine.
I love that I can get 75 vitamins, minerals and nutrients from whole food sources just
by adding a scoop of AG1 to my smoothie in the morning, or mixing it with a glass of
It’s a really simple habit to get into, and it’s so much easier than swallowing
a bunch of pills, which is what I did for years and came to completely dread.
AG1 is different, and it makes me feel grateful that even during the most chaotic times in
my life, I can do this small, powerful thing to help me cover my nutritional bases every
If you’re looking for an easier way to take supplements, Athletic Greens is giving you
a free one-year supply of vitamin D and five free travel packs with your first purchase.
Go to athleticgreens.com slash witchtrials.
That’s athleticgreens.com slash witchtrials.
Check it out.
This podcast is supported by fastgrowingtrees.com.
I had to make a confession to my husband before I married him.
I do not have a good history with plants, specifically with keeping them alive.
And now that our daughter is four years old, I wanted to make sure that my arboreal deficiencies
aren’t passed along for another generation.
And here’s where fastgrowingtrees.com comes in.
Fastgrowingtrees.com showed us our growing zone based on our location, and then we used
the plant finder to help us choose the perfect trees for little hands to help tend.
And for people like me, who sadly miss the genes for a green thumb, fastgrowingtrees.com
has plant experts who curate thousands of easy-to-grow plant, shrub, and tree varieties
for each unique climate, from apple trees to evergreens and everything in between.
Plus, their plant experts are always available to help keep our plants growing healthy
throughout the season and beyond.
And I can’t wait to harvest our Meyer lemons and key limes with my little girl when the time comes.
You can join over 1.5 million happy Fast Growing Trees customers
by going to fastgrowingtrees.com slash witchtrials now to get 15% off your entire order.
Get 15% off at fastgrowingtrees.com slash witchtrials.
A part of the folklore around Harry Potter, which turns out to be true, is that originally
the first book was rejected by 12 different publishers before finally someone was willing to put it out.
Publishing wants to be with the zeitgeist, which is, you know, a business decision.
I think sometimes they make mistakes.
And what they think is the zeitgeist is a very particular and narrow view of the zeitgeist,
but that’s another discussion.
The people who rejected it should be fired, obviously.
This is Charles, a.k.a. Chip.
My name is Chip McGrath. I’m the former editor of the New York Times Book Review.
Formerly the head of the biggest books department in publishing.
I’m going to say 1995 to 2004.
So this is right when Harry Potter blew up.
Nobody anticipated that it was going to do as well as it did.
And this is Kat.
So my name is Kat Rosenfield. I’m a culture writer and the author of five books, including two young adult novels.
Even after Rowling was finally able to get a publisher.
When it was first purchased, it was not anticipated to be a particularly big book.
They only printed 500 copies.
The publishers, both the ones that rejected the book and the one that finally agreed to put it out,
they just felt like it wasn’t of the moment.
I think there were three things going on with the book.
Firstly, boarding school, passe. No one’s going to be interested.
Secondly, it’s too long. So the first one’s 95,000 words.
And I can’t even remember how long Phoenix is, Order of the Phoenix, but little did they know what was coming.
And then thirdly, I don’t think it was necessarily, it might have been that he was a boy.
One of the issues was about gender. In particular, the fact that Rowling was a woman.
So then they want me to not use my first name. They want me to use my initials.
They were concerned that a woman’s name on the front of the book would discourage boys from wanting to read it.
This has always been a concern in publishing. How do we get boys to read?
And so this pen name, J.K. Rowling, was selected at the behest of the publishers.
Joanne Rowling doesn’t even have a middle name. The famous J.K. was made up just for the books.
There was an understanding, I think, at this point that the novel was going to have limited appeal already.
So this was a way of trying to attract more readers choosing a gender neutral name.
In 1997, the 500 copies of the book were distributed to bookstores and libraries.
The first time I saw the book in a bookshop. Now that to me was a bigger deal than I can express to you.
I am a published writer. Look, there it is.
Do you remember where you first saw it in a shop?
I remember vividly.
It’s actually not there anymore. It was a Waterstones, a mainstream book outlet.
And I genuinely didn’t go in there to look for it. I went in there to buy a picture book for my daughter.
And I turned and I looked at the R section of the chapter books.
And I was, as I thought, it will be there.
I saw it.
It’s a completely unknown book. There’s no fanfare. There was no big launch party.
It wasn’t in the window.
No, of course not. It’s just quietly appeared on the shelf.
And it was one of the best moments of my life.
It was the most incredible feeling.
There was very little marketing budget.
But it became clear fairly early on that children were telling children about the book.
It’s like a chain reaction. Everybody gets involved with that.
Yeah, in my class, like, you didn’t read Harry Potter?
Yeah, like two days later, it was so good, wasn’t it?
It was word of mouth. It started to get bigger and bigger.
It’s very different. It’s not like a normal, average book.
It’s like so imaginative. It’s so detailed. It’s almost like watching the book instead of reading it.
Quickly, those 500 copies they originally printed became 30,000 copies.
And then, in less than a year, Scholastic Books, one of the biggest publishers in the U.S., picked up the book.
If you don’t know it, your children almost certainly do.
It was everywhere.
A little boy named Harry Potter is working magic in the world of books.
Harry Potter is an old-fashioned, good-triumphs-over-evil story, but full of quirks and surprises.
This idea of an orphan boy, abused, neglected, unwanted, who suddenly gets a mysterious letter telling him there’s a whole other world out there, with a place for him in it.
This idea that in this other world, full of adventure and danger, giants and dragons, good and evil, he’ll find his friends, his identity, his courage to do great things.
This idea that Rowling came up with on the train in 1990, it just profoundly connected with so many people.
And as its success grew, Rowling’s own life started to become part of the story.
Joanne Rowling, a 34-year-old single mother and currently the world’s most successful author, lives and writes in the shadow of Edinburgh Castle.
I mean, she is the subject, then, of this sort of mythologizing.
And while she thought of herself as a writer, she had never published anything.
I mean, her story is, in a way, it’s like a Harry Potter story itself. It’s a kind of a fairy tale.
Jo Rowling’s rise to success is this sort of feminist Cinderella story.
What makes Jo Rowling’s success all the more remarkable is what it follows.
She had few friends and fewer prospects, and ended up on welfare, actually skipping meals to make sure she had enough money for her four-month-old baby.
You have a single mom on welfare who writes this book that changes the course of the culture.
Her agent says that Rowling, barely five years away from welfare, could end up making $100 million.
This is a book about a woman who’s been on welfare for a long time.
I was so ill-equipped for what happened to me.
Now, I was grateful. I was hugely grateful that the work was loved.
That part brought me nothing but joy.
And materially speaking, I mean, my life had been transformed.
At that point, I was living in a world where I had no money.
And materially speaking, I mean, my life had been transformed.
At that point, I was living for the first time I’d been able to buy a house.
But I was scared.
What was happening to me in terms of fame was outstripping me constantly.
So I buy this very ordinary house that’s standing on a very nice, ordinary street.
And I’ve got journalists parked outside my front door. They’re within feet of my front door.
So, you know, I felt like I was playing catch-up all the time with the situation.
It was changing faster than you could respond to it.
It was changing far faster than I could deal with.
And all the time, I have this lurking fear because I know that there’s someone out there who does not wish me well.
So, you know, that was strange.
And then, well, to tell you the truth, the reason we left that first place was my ex-husband arrived and broke in.
Yeah. So moving became quite a pressing issue at that point.
In the middle of all of this, you’re still worried. You have not escaped your husband.
You see, this is the insanity of it, OK?
I’m trying to retain, you know, like an iron wall around my location as well because everyone wants to come.
Can I photograph you at home? No, you can’t photograph me at home. Why not?
You’re being so precious. You’re being so starry.
And it’s not that at all. It was quite the reverse.
It’s because the last time my ex-husband knew my address, he turned up and broke in.
What was that like? I mean, you’re this rising star and you’re still trying to hide.
I think that’s actually the most accurate summary of my situation I’ve ever heard.
You know, try and reconcile suddenly having a lot of press interest with really, really wanting to live under the radar for very concrete reasons.
You know, not because I thought I was Salinger, not because, you know, I’m Greta Garbo, but because…
You’re on safety.
I was living in a state of real tension that I couldn’t express to many people.
And yet, with the release of each new book, the Harry Potter phenomenon broke new records.
There were midnight release parties where, all over the world,
thousands of people lined up or camped out all night.
At midnight, less than one hour from now, the new Harry Potter book goes on sale here in Southern California.
Potter fans in other cities like London, where children actually slept outside bookstores overnight when the latest in the series was going on sale.
I mean, the thing about the Potter thing was it went on and on and on. I mean, it was a publishing whirlwind.
It’s unprecedented in American children’s books. It’s unprecedented in English children’s books.
There’s nothing that compares to the velocity of the success of Harry Potter.
And it’s not just kids. Adults are into Harry Potter, too.
Well, I started out buying them for my grandson, who’s very young, and then I started reading them, and I liked them so well, I kept buying.
You really feel you know this character.
It was increasingly difficult to describe how big it was.
This is really nothing that can be compared to a normal success.
People kept trying to kind of outdo themselves in terms of their superlative language.
The largest printing of a book ever. The fastest selling book ever.
It was, somebody is picking up Harry Potter every 30 seconds.
The books are now in 26 languages and 140 countries.
The Potter books are available in 200 countries and translated into 46 languages.
It was really insane.
As we crossed over into the year 2000, suddenly everything seemed to just supersize itself.
Everything, from my point of view, became a bit more crazy.
It all became so much that it started to seem like too much.
J.K. Rowling had created an uncanny world, and the phenomenon that surrounded it was itself becoming uncanny.
I was signing for like 2,000 people at a time.
You’ve got fights breaking out in the car park.
You’ve got security there.
Just the enormity of it brought this tension.
There is something about a mass of human beings.
There’s always an edge in a crowd, always.
And in 2000, at a big crowded book signing…
We had a bomb threat at one store from allegedly a far-right Christian.
Allegedly a far-right Christian person.
It was clear by this time that there was a mounting backlash to Harry Potter.
As we approach the 21st century, it doesn’t take a rocket scientist to recognize that our entire culture is in trouble.
We’re staring down the barrel of a loaded gun, and we can no longer afford to act like it’s loaded with blanks.
And a movement was growing to stop Rowling and ban her books.
Things are getting a little bit nervy at this point, you know.
We’re in a moral freefall.
When your children can be taught witchcraft by Harry Potter, that Heather has two mummies,
you can let your daughter go to school and she can get an abortion without your permission or without your knowledge.
Something is dreadfully wrong when you as the parent cannot control the destiny of your own child.
America has turned its back on the God of the Bible,
and it’s time for the Church of Jesus Christ to stand up and speak up
and say we have a right to the destiny of our own children.
You’ve been listening to The Witch Trials of J.K. Rowling.
Produced by Andy Mills, Matthew Boll, and me, Megan Phelps-Roper.
And brought to you by The Free Press.
Our sincere thanks to you for listening.
And we would love to listen to you, too.
If you have any questions or thoughts for us, feel free to email us at
And we would love to listen to you, too.
If you have any questions or thoughts for us, feel free to email us at
This podcast is brought to you by The Free Press.
The Free Press is a new kind of media company trying to help restore trust in journalism
at a time when that trust is at a historic all-time low.
And we’re doing that by printing stories, hosting debates, and publishing a wide range of opinion pieces,
all in an effort to break out of echo chambers and fight against confirmation bias
and see the world as the complicated and sometimes wonderful mess that it really is.
If that sounds like something you value, become a subscriber today at thefp.com.
If that sounds like something you value, become a subscriber today at thep.com.